A prolonged discussion on the future of the Cross Street carpark in Double Bay highlighted differing views on redevelopment and funding as councillors reviewed options for the ageing structure.
Background on the Site
Built in the 1970s, the Cross Street carpark includes community facilities, an early childhood health centre and more than 400 parking spaces. An independent assessment presented to authorities estimated remediation costs ranging from $25.6 million to $38.6 million.
During a meeting on 26 November 2025, city officials spent more than two hours debating whether adequate due diligence had been completed. The discussion referred to previous community consultation undertaken in 2023 and how it should influence current planning work.
Details of the Redevelopment Option
A redevelopment plan outlined by council staff proposes a $50 million rebuild funded by subdividing and selling 38 per cent of the site. The option includes a five-storey, 412-space carpark with one underground level. Construction is expected to begin in 2028 and finish in 2030.
This approach, according to the council explanation, would allow the new facility to be delivered without cost to ratepayers.
Alternative Approaches Considered
Authorities reviewed remediation options costing $26 million for a ten-year lifespan or $38 million for a 25-year extension. The debate also reflected long-standing community involvement, with some representatives noting that feedback over several decades had shaped expectations for the site. Others expressed the view that further consultation was necessary before any commitment.
Community Sentiment and Meeting Outcome
Tensions during the 26 November meeting led to a short adjournment before discussion resumed. Concerns were raised about the consultation process, while others emphasised the responsibility of elected representatives to make a decision based on available information.
The meeting concluded with unanimous agreement to place the preferred redevelopment option on public exhibition, consistent with requirements for land sales under council policy.
Next Steps
Public consultation will open from 27 January to 25 February 2026 through the council’s community engagement platform. An information session will be held on 3 February 2026, providing residents with further detail on the Cross Street carpark proposal in Double Bay.
Published 7-Dec-2025
